Social CRM – The Migraine Edition
I’ve been a buying computing hardware as a business customer from Dell for over 7 years now. All of our infrastructure technology as well as desktop equipment almost exclusively came from them. Servers, Printers, Laptops etc.
My experience, averaged out over this period with Dell has been a net positive. Their stuff works, the service and follow up has generally been good. A few issues such as a customer satisfaction calls at 6:30am (!?!), too many requests for equipment identification numbers after I’ve entered it into the touch tone system as I get volleyed from support rep to support rep. I can live with some of this as we don’t have reasons to call that often. And as a person, I’m generally not one to dwell unless you really get my goat.
Then a serious problem hit a few days ago where I really needed Dell to come through for me. My under-warranty hard drive was about to fail which would mean all my purchased software was about to be wiped out. So I asked Dell for replacement copies of software and the “its Microsoft’s problem” syndrome kicked in. So I went back and forth between these two ‘partners’ who’s reps had expert reasons for why the problem wasn’t theirs to solve.
During this, all I could think of is that the Dell has all the data concerning my purchase and loyalty history for seven straight years and yet, they wouldn’t budge to make this as simple as possible for me. When I mentioned to the these vendors that I have registered the software when I made the purchase (incase, the issue here was verification that I was the lawful owner), I was told, this information is captured only for future marketing purposes and that customer support doesn’t get access to this data. Wait, my taking the time to register my software is to serve you and not me?
Please note my first comment: My experience with Dell is a net positive in spite of this. And as much as its unpopular in many circles to say you like Microsoft products, except for Vista, I really do like their stuff, personally. So this is not about these providers in particular.
The point is, CRM is a mess. Internal departments are not sharing my customer profile to appreciate my historical allegiance to the organization. OEM partners who had to collaborate to have the slightest chance at winning my business are not sharing data amongst themselves. Even when they know that keeping me as a long term customer is predicated on them both serving me equally well. As organizations, we just don’t have a handle on how to use what we already know about the customer.
As tempting it is to add to the chorus of many altruistic “CRM got it all wrong and Social CRM is here to reinvent customer interaction” or for that matter, “SCRM is strategy and not technology” (is it? or is it an execution path to established business strategy?) blog posts, Social CRM is going to accentuate the problems of CRM. The thing with SocialCRM is that it adds more customer data to CRM records when many organizations have not learnt how to act on existing data. Whist a quick look at my Twitter usage can give Dell an idea of my profile, what good will that do if organizations are not going to act on hard data they have today: How much I’ve spent with them over the years, my active registrations of software I’ve purchased, my loyalty based on the fact that I religiously buy new equipment from them every year.
So whilst we look at newly minted Gartner Magic Quadrants on Social CRM providers (Jive Software offers a copy here with registration), organizations need to understand how much house cleaning they need to do first. And unless that happens, SocialCRM only gives organizations a data migraine – more info that they don’t know what to do with.
Paul Greenberg, who sits at the pinnacle of the ‘whose who’ digerati when it comes to CRM and Social CRM has an excellent write up today about Gartner’s Magic Quadrant and the Gartner Event on Social CRM. A central point of this post is that whilst community and engagement are important and vendors to date have made solid progress, Social CRM integration with CRM to truly improve customer relationships is critical. And that nut has not been cracked yet. When the report was released a few days ago, I said to Mitch Lieberman, another SCRM thought leader on twitter:
“@mjayliebs those in the Gartner MQ #SCRM leader quadrant better have figured out lead gen in a meaningful, budget shifting way. think not”
My larger point (140 characters don’t often lend well to making larger points) was that this needs to move from community to supporting business tasks and an overall CRM initiative whether that is lead gen, or in my case, customer service and the like. In the case of my issue with Dell, everyone needed access to the same hard data (my company profile, purchase history), my probability of remaining a Dell/Microsoft customer based on my social graph , my in-warranty status on hardware and all OEM software (see that I was the legitimate owner of the software and simply wanted a replacement copy and only thanks to an in warranty failed hard drive).
We tend to think that using media monitoring and listening systems reduces noise and let is focus on things that matter in our customer relationships. I respectfully disagree. Until its surgically helping you execute business and process objectives more effectively, its still noise. I asked Esteban Kolsky, a respected CRM analyst to chime in:
We have seen the positive effects that monitoring social media and acting on it in real time can have in an organization. Even Dell, mentioned in this example, managed to earn some money in social media be leveraging real-time, social marketing. However, that is not SCRM. Social CRM is where the social data and the transactional data are analyzed together to create deeper insights that ever before. Using Social data we can amplify what we know about customers by adding a sentimental, emotional layer to what we know — and that helps smart companies drive sales cycles and create better revenue models. Are we there yet? not even close, we first need to figure out a way to integrate the socially-collected data with stored transactional data, then how to create better insights, and finally how to to act on them. Yes, it is a lot of work — but the rewards far surpass any amount of work you have to put into it.
Failing house cleaning on existing CRM design and decisive use of Social data as part of that revamp, we’ll just have glorified community forums that no doubt look far more sexier than forums of yore, but don’t mean much when it comes to tacking large scale operating and growth objectives of organizations.
